I’ve always been a fan of certain types of romance books and thrillers. When I started writing my first novel, I decided to combine the two. How hard could it be? Man, was I in for a roller coaster ride.
My first editor: “Not enough romance. Make it less thriller and more romance.”
Beta-reader: “Not enough action. Take out some of the romance scenes and replace them with fighting scenes.”
Beta-reader: “Where’s the psychological intrigue? Thriller books are only good if they mess with your head.”
So, I took a deep breath and rewrote the entire novel, trying to incorporate everything they said.
My second editor: “Not enough world-building. You need to describe things more. And don’t forget those inner thoughts. Readers want to know what your characters are feeling.”
Beta-reader: “Not enough romance. Where’s the heat? And your characters are too goody two-shoes. They need to have more darkness inside them.”
Beta-reader: “I love Michael. I want to see more of him. Make the scenes with the other characters fewer and focus more on Ruby and Michael. And crank up the drama. It makes characters more believable.”
Phew, writing this novel was getting harder and harder. So many voices.
I took another long breath and rewrote the entire novel again.
My third editor: “Love it, but all those inner thoughts need to be in italics so it could read like a dialogue. And your contractions are all wrong. You need to keep them short and consistent.”
Beta-reader: “Too many descriptions. It’s hindering the pace. Lose the heat. Make it more closed-door. I like your twists, but there needs to be more of them. Make your ending more intense. It would be super cool if Michael and Liam ended up fighting each other. ”
Beta-reader: “I love the relationship between Ruby and Michael, but we need to see more of the other characters as well. Poor Eric needs to find his happily ever after, too. And I love the humor between the characters; bring in more of that.”
By now, I didn’t have any breath left to heave. The person who said writing a novel is easy needs a hard slap against the head.
I squared my shoulder, raised my chin, and rewrote the book the way I wanted it to be. Like I should’ve done from the start.
You can’t please every reader. Sometimes, you just have to go with your gut. That’s the lesson I’ve learned throughout my entire journey: follow your heart, then your head, and then your gut. And keep at it. Sometimes, it takes four drafts to get you to something you like and can be proud of.